When it comes to disclosing something as personal as having herpes, the question of whether to do it in person or over text often arises. I’ve been through this situation more times than I care to count, and in that time, I’ve learned valuable lessons about how, when, and where to have these difficult conversations. In my experience, one method stands out as the clear winner, but there are nuances to consider, depending on the circumstances. Here’s my perspective, based on my personal journey and reflections.
In Person Is Way Better
If you’re debating between telling someone in person or over text, I can tell you right off the bat—in person is by far the better option. There are several reasons why this approach is more successful and more respectful for both you and your potential partner.
First, when you disclose in person, you have the opportunity to control the conversation. You can explain your situation fully, listen to their thoughts in real time, and clear up any misconceptions. There’s a certain level of vulnerability in being face-to-face with someone, but it’s also a level of honesty that can only come through direct interaction. When you’re sitting there, speaking with someone, they can hear the sincerity in your voice, see the emotion on your face, and witness your body language. All of these elements humanize you in a way that a text message simply cannot.
Another major advantage of telling someone in person is that it prevents any misunderstandings that might arise from a text message. It’s easy for things to get lost in translation when you’re communicating through written words. In addition, if you’re worried about your disclosure being shared with others, there’s always the possibility that a screenshot of your message could end up in the wrong hands. That’s a risk you eliminate by having the conversation face-to-face. Being present, with all the nuance of a real-time interaction, ensures your partner sees you as a person first, and not just a virus.
The Importance of Human Connection
One of the most important factors in a successful disclosure is the emotional connection you share with the other person. I strongly believe that disclosing in person allows your partner to see you as a whole human being—not just someone carrying an STI. When I first started dating after being diagnosed with HSV, I used to worry constantly about how my partner would perceive me after learning about my status. Over time, I realized that being open about it in person not only helped me feel more comfortable, but it also helped my partners see me for who I truly was.
When you’re sitting together and discussing such a personal matter, they can hear your voice, sense the compassion in your words, and understand that you’re not just a statistic or a diagnosis. You’re a human being with your own story, and you deserve to be treated with the same respect as anyone else. It’s not easy to have this conversation, but the way it changes the dynamic between two people can be profound.
Being there in person allows you to gauge their immediate reaction, which can be helpful in understanding where they stand emotionally. It’s a lot harder for someone to react negatively or to avoid you when you’re right there in front of them. Even if their initial reaction is a bit of surprise or hesitation, you have the chance to calm their concerns, provide information, and let them process it on their terms.
Disclosure During the STD Testing Conversation
One of the approaches I’ve adopted in my dating life is to bring up my herpes diagnosis only when the topic of STD testing comes up. In my experience, discussing testing is a natural and responsible step when you’re becoming intimate with someone. I ask any new partner to get tested, and I let them know that I’ll be doing the same—specifically for STIs like Gonorrhea, Chlamydia, HIV, HPV, Syphilis, and of course, HSV.
For me, this has become a comfortable way to talk about herpes. It doesn’t feel like I’m burdening the other person with information; instead, it feels like a part of the broader conversation about health and safety. The reality is that most people who have herpes are asymptomatic and don’t even know they have it. That’s why testing is so important.
I’ve had a lot of conversations where people have confided in me that they, too, have HSV but haven’t disclosed it to their partners because they’re afraid of judgment. The truth is, that people who are asymptomatic and don’t get tested are often the ones perpetuating the stigma around herpes. By being open about your diagnosis, you create a safe space for your partner to do the same, and together, you can navigate this part of your relationship with honesty and transparency.
Why Texting Is Usually a Mistake
While I’ve seen some people disclose their herpes status via text, in my opinion, it’s usually not the best method. Texting lacks the personal connection that you get with an in-person conversation, and the tone of your message can easily be misinterpreted. You don’t get the benefit of seeing how your words land on the other person in real time, and this can create unnecessary misunderstandings.
Plus, there’s always the risk of the text being shared or forwarded, especially if the person you’re telling reacts poorly. This can lead to feelings of embarrassment, and in some cases, can even damage your reputation. Once a message is out there, it’s out of your control, and that’s something I personally try to avoid. I’d much rather have the conversation face-to-face, where I can immediately address any questions or concerns and guide the conversation in a more constructive direction.
A Personal Experience with Text Disclosure
That being said, there are times when disclosing by text can be effective, especially if you’re trying to save time or avoid wasting emotional energy. For example, if you’re just starting to date someone and you sense that they might not be open to a relationship with someone who has herpes, texting can allow you to be upfront without having to invest too much time or energy. For me, this became a way to set boundaries early in the dating process.
When I first started disclosing my HSV status over text, I was nervous, but I realized it wasn’t something to be ashamed of. It’s just a part of my life. Over time, I became more comfortable with it. In fact, disclosing by text allowed me to connect with others who also had HSV, and in some cases, it led to deep, supportive relationships. It helped me understand that I wasn’t alone in this experience.
In-Person Disclosure Wins
The best approach for disclosing herpes is in person, when possible. It allows for a deeper connection, provides you with the chance to explain things in detail, and ensures that your partner sees you as a person, not just a diagnosis. While texting can be effective in certain situations, it often lacks the emotional connection that’s needed to truly have an open and honest conversation. Above all, be proud of who you are, and don’t let your diagnosis define you. You deserve love and respect, just like anyone else. Whether in person or via text, the most important thing is to be truthful, kind, and compassionate with yourself and your partner.
Leave a Reply